I have been thinking a lot about how a couple goes about establishing an egalitarian romantic relationship. I have been in many unequal, unhealthy and damaging relationships with men in my life - some more damaging then others. I always lived under the assumption that I would have to just settle for some man and he would be "good enough" and living the heterosexual, "normal" little life would make me sooo happy.
When I was growing up, I was told that "All men do ___" and "All men want ___ from you, so just grin and bear it" I felt as though my role in life was to find a man, keep the man and somehow find happieness from the man. How sad. Of course, when you find a man, you realize how fucked up everything can be - how totally ridiculous and absurd it all can be. Growing up, after I hit about 13, All i wanted to do was think about boys and boyfriends. I always had this romantisized view of being swept away by some amazingly perfect man. Sadly, I ended up meeting men who never considered a woman's struggle or anything beyond mundane bullshit. I always based my self-esteem on how males viewed me growing up, and since I wasn't "pretty" until a dude told me i was after i was about 15, I had a bad self-image.
Now, when i think about the possibility of children (which is 0% in my life) I always think about what i would not do, or say to a daughter...So many young girls base their self-worth on what men think of them, and it's not a conscious choice, it's something that is slowly constructed over a period of time. It wasn't until I met the man i am living with now, that I realized that he and i both had a responsibility to maintain equality and abolish all gender roles in our relationship. Now, again, this didn't happen overnight. This happened after I started to discover myself and what i wanted. I began to look at women as a class, and their struggle in and out of relationships (since intimate partners account for a shitload of crimes against women). When i began to dissect my idea of "normal", i began to realize how i didn't fit into the hetero-normative idea of "love" and also how i didn't want to fit into it. Why? Because hetero-normativity is constructed socially and it is damaging.
So how do you have an egalitarian relationship with anyone? either gender, whatever...? It's fucking work. It's hard work. You have to be willing (and your partner) to dissect yourself, your intentions and almost every aspect of your life. You have to be willing to change, to revolutionize your relationship to avoid exploitation, objectification and power struggles. That's fucking hard. So many women are in relationships with men who believe exploitation, objectification and power struggles to be natural and thus will not change. Is it worth being with someone who isn't willing to throw away gender norms like masculinity to be with you? I mean, really. I'm not saying that women need to pair up with men, or with anyone for that matter...simply that if you do want to, i think it's important for feminists to make the private egalitarian, too. As everyone knows how we love to bring the private and expose the shit out of it to the public. So, if you are inclined towards men, educate them. If they are unwilling to look and examine their privilege, than it's not worth losing yourself.
And just to add, I realize that this post is a bit all over the place, but that's what blogs are for sometimes....
I like this post!! My romantic relationship is one of the, if not THE, most important things in my life. I work REALLY, REALLY HARD to keep the communication flowing and the resentment off our backs. Now, I would NEVER consider living with a man because negotiating across the gender hierarchy is too much work. Dealing with another woman-- my supposed social equal!-- is difficult enough.
ReplyDeleteHowever, for those who DO like teh menz, I think feminism needs to focus more on women's EMOTIONAL ADDICTION to male attention and approval. Like you said:
So many young girls base their self-worth on what men think of them, and it's not a conscious choice, it's something that is slowly constructed over a period of time.
The one time I had a boyfriend, he was really super, extra nice to me. That was good and all. But then my entire LIFE and HAPPINESS revolved around his approval. It's very dangerous. (And this is not to say that my female partner's approval is not important to me, it is. But not in the same ways that women DEPEND on male attention in general to get them through the day)
In order to keep things working with my wife, I have a LOT of fighting rules to keep us in check. For example, not saying things you don't mean, no matter how mad you are (including name calling!). Do not use ALWAYS/NEVER unless you have at least 3-4 concrete examples to back it up. Do NOT walk away from me in the middle of a fight. Always agree to make a change at the end of the conversation (ie, I promise to try to be more conscious of your feelings and not do that/do something different next time, if you also try to let me know how your feel with words b/c I can't read your mind).
So yeah, DAILY WORK. And constant negotiation. It's not easy, kids. But it sure doesn't happen via MAGIC either. That's a bunch of shit men sell women so that we'll always blame ourselves for not being happy enough-- when in fact, it is the female ROLE itself that sucks our souls dry, not the inability to perform it properly.
In conclusion,
And just to add, I realize that this post is a bit all over the place, but that's what blogs are for sometimes....
Hell YES. That is precisely what blogs are for! ;)
I really liked the rules - so much so that i think i should try and use some of them...I have a bad habit of "always" and "never" and saying things i didn't mean...need to work on that!
ReplyDeletebut yeah, 95% or more of my relationships in the past with men have been unequal, i mean, i was also a very very very different person back then so i don't think i even thought of it...i just 'accepted' everything the way it was 'supposed' to be in my eyes. blargh! bad memories!!!
Thanks, Owl Eyes. It's definitely an uphill battle with men! I cannot even put my mind there!
ReplyDeleteAlso, it's really hard to train yourself not to WILE out in emotion. But when you get really comfortable with someone, I think it's a LOT easier because you have earned a certain kind of faith that things will be addressed in the the way you need them to be....eventually.
Anyways, here's a link to a post I wrote with a few more rules for keeping things fair(ish):
http://undercoverpunk.wordpress.com/2009/12/18/9-years/
Hell yeah, egalitarian relationships (especially between a woman and a man) are hard work. 99% of my relationships have been abusive, so it is still really weird to me that not only can my current partner and I disagree (with no physical or emotional consequence to me) but we can speak openly and work things out together. He has grown a lot from my influence (stopped porn usage and has become aware of his privilege as a man, and now considers himself a pro-radfem) and I have grown a lot from his emotional support and encouragement. It is hard work to try and keep communication open and also balance everyday tasks, but it is worth it. It has also been extremely important to us to be equal and honest when it comes to sex. We had been fed the lie of the benefits of BDSM, but together we have broken free of that and embraced a mutual sexuality which hardly includes intercourse, and never actions which mimic abuse. As a rape survivor that has been hugely important to me - to have complete body autonomy. Our relationship has been a rollercoaster, but it really has opened up a new dimension of humanity for us.
ReplyDelete@noexcusenomercy
ReplyDeleteI think if more couples really just tried to et rid of the restrictions of gender roles, relationships would be better off and much less harmful and unequal. It took me so long to realize that I had to put work in as much as they did...I didn't get that people could just be human instead of "manly" or "lady like" or whatever...the bullshit that keeps us unhappy in relationships.
I think with sex, too...it's huge...since so many people don't believe the private should be looked at...I think it's huge to try to have mutual sexuality that is free from power struggles. I think it's so awesome that your partner has realized his priv. too, this is something mine has been working on for the last year or so. I think feminism has made his life better as it has with mine, you know?
Thank you for sharing, i'm loving the comments on this post :D
Great entry! And I could certainly relate. In the past I had a boyfriend who totally threw away masculinity while we were alone together, it was when we went on in public, with our friends or talking to a waitor that he talked to me in that condescending way, and made those blokey misogynist jokes. ugh.
ReplyDeleteYou know that old saying, about the master keeping us occupied with his concerns?
ReplyDeleteEven creating egalitarian relationships with men is women's work. If you want a man to respect you, you have to teach him. *sigh* Women's work never ends...
My husband said the movie "made in dagaeham" was a a brilliant movie I would enjoy about women who won the battle of equal pay. I then said "oh, so it is fiction!" He didn't understand the "joke".
ReplyDeleteMost of us walk through life assuming the other "understands". I had to remind him that women DO NOT GET EQUAL PAY. Freedom is achieved only when we are all given the same opportunities.